The Tradition of Thanksgiving and the Ritual of Black Friday

Thanksgiving 2012 has come and gone. For many of us the day could not have arrived soon enough. Making traveling plans, actually getting there or preparing to receive guests over-taxed our minds and bodies. As we were passing time with family and friends our thoughts drifted to how to mercifully end the day. Many people traveled by air to spend the day with someone who made the trip worth while. For the American airline industry Thanksgiving Day represents one of the busiest air travel days of the year. A lot of people who I know opted to drive to or from some place to celebrate Thanksgiving. Not surprisingly; gasoline prices seem to creep higher once Thanksgiving rolls around. Thanksgiving can be a joyous and stressful time of the year.

Many Americans, like me, spent Thanksgiving Day at home. I spent day with a fellow alumnus of my college. We graduated from college in 1975 and had not communicated with each other since then. In college we were good friends and members of the track squad. She and her husband had already planned a trip to NYC during Thanksgiving. Facebook led her to me and we made all the arrangements to meet. Neither she nor her husband had ever visited NYC. They had decided to attend the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade and visit Midtown at mid-night. I was looking forward to their visit and invited them to stay at my home.

Most people would agree that the significance of Thanksgiving has changed radically over the last few years. The day has morphed from a solemn occasion of giving thanks to a stepping stone to a commercialized shopping day know as a Black Friday (BF) that kicks off the Christmas Holiday shopping season. During this time retailers hope to change their bottom lines from red to black.

The true significance of Thanksgiving seems to have gotten lost in the media advertising blitz that heralds in BF. We need to take a moment to recall the true reason why we give thanks on Thanksgiving Day.

To understand America’s giving thanks on the third Thursday in November one must travel historically backwards in time to the early 1600s. Only a small number of the original pilgrims survived the after landing at Plymouth Rock. The survivors harvested their crops and gathered to celebrate and give thanks to God for allowing them to survive and conquer all challenges. Governor Bradford of the 1620 Pilgrim Colony of Plymouth called the pilgrims to the town meeting-house to “render Thanksgiving to the Almighty God for all His blessings.” The local Native Americans were invited to the feast. Some people have suggested that the day should not be celebrated out of respect for the eventual displacement of the American Indian and destruction of their way of life. Those who suggest that we should not celebrate Thanksgiving are small in number.

Since 1620 America has officially celebrated the day in some form or another. However, Abraham Lincoln is generally credited with having made Thanksgiving Day a national holiday. During the height of the American Civil War when Americans were killing each other in horrific bloody battles he issued his Thanksgiving Day proclamation by declaring in part:

“…announced in the Holy Scriptures and proven by all history, that those nations are blessed whose God is the Lord… But we have forgotten God. We have forgotten the gracious hand which preserved us in peace and multiplied and enriched and strengthened us, and we have vainly imagined, by the deceitfulness of our hearts, that all these blessings were produced by some superior wisdom and virtue of our own… It has seemed to me fit and proper that God should be solemnly, reverently and gratefully acknowledged, as with one heart and one voice, by the whole American people…”

Since President Lincoln’s proclamation of October 3, 1863 America has celebrated Thanksgiving as a national holiday on the third Thursday in November. I think it is poignant that Thanksgiving became a fixture of American society and culture during this country’s rebirth (the Civil War) as a nation.

I remember celebrating Thanksgiving during the 60’s and 70’s. During those years most American’s viewed the holiday as a solemn moment when friends and family came to gather to share a meal and to give thanks just for the opportunity to gather and share. The following day was always considered the beginning of the Christmas shopping season. The day had not yet become the year’s premier shopping day. I distinctly remember that most retail stores were closed on Thanksgiving Day. They reopened the following day at their regular opening hour. Families and friends were able to enjoy each others’ company and food without being distracted by the constant barrage of sales and promotions. Also, the consumer was not offered extended or early shopping hours. During Thanksgiving Day we were able to concentrate on socializing with each other. To me; Thanksgiving offered a time to reconnect with each other on an intimate and personal level. Companionship and  friendship cannot be overvalued or taken for granted.

America’s Dance at the Edge of the Fiscal Cliff

Every once in a while each one of us sits down with pencil and paper to go over our budget. We are determined to make sure that our expenses can be covered by our income. If it is discovered that we might be operating in the red we panic mode sets in. We look for ways to close the budget gap. Businesses go through the same process but on a larger and more technical scale. The universal quest is to have a balanced budget. After the financial crisis of 2007-2008 no one wants to finance their budgets by taking on more and more credit. Money borrowed must be repaid with interest. Substantial interest payments can break any well thought out and controlled budget.

Unfortunately the Eurozone nations (EZ) and to a lesser degree the United States find themselves struggling with a sovereign debt issue. The European financial bloc has struggled for the past two years to bring its member nation’s national debt down to sustainable levels. The EZ has had to bail out the economies of Greece, Portugal and Iceland to prevent their economies from collapsing. Politicians, financial organizations, experts and an assortment of pundits have debated the appropriateness of stimulation packages versus austerity measures. Spending more money to stimulate an economy is politically popular but, in the end, might exacerbate the debt problem. Austerity measures are designed to cut back governmental spending and lessen its role in supporting the economy. Because austerity normally leads to drastic changes in the standard of living residents have taken the European streets to protest the hardships that go with drastic reductions in governmental spending. On November 8, 2012 the Greek parliament again approved a series of austerity measures which legislators hope will entitle the nation to continued bailout funds. The debate of the measures and their final approval was greeted by street protests and wild-cat strikes. Austerity measures have often provoked massive protests and civil unrest. For the time being it seems that Greece will continue as a member the EZ.

The contentious U.S. presidential election is finally over. Most Americans are happy that they will no longer be bombarded with campaign ads loaded with political rhetoric that the candidates have not intention of adhering to. President Obama won reelection and he deserves to be congratulated.

Before November 6, 2012 it was generally agreed that budget woes awaited the winner of the election.  An excellent piece appeared in the Atlanta Daily World about the problems the winner would face. Last year Congress passed the Budget Control Act of 2011 (Budget Act) which was signed by President Obama. The Budget Act was a response to the political debate surrounding the need to continuously raise the nation’s debt ceiling. Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner told CNN that a deal had to be reached. He argued that America’s faith and credit should not be held hostage to politics. Experts had predicted that if the debt ceiling was not raised there would be higher interests rates, home values would sink even lower, the stock markets would lose much of their value and a half of million jobs would be lost.

Last year it seemed like there was universal support for raising the nation’s debt limit. There was much disagreement on the terms and condition for raising it. Because Congress was not able to agree on a permanent solution to the U.S.’s growing sovereign debt problem the nation’s legislators agreed to sever cuts in various programs, impose spending caps, increasing debt ceilings and to allow certain tax exemptions to expire. These automatic measures are to take effect on January 1, 2013 if no further legislative compromise can be reached.

The legislation also established the “Super-Committee.” This is a 12 man committee with 3 members from each party and each chamber of Congress. This group was tasked with cutting the deficit by $1.2 trillion over the next ten years. If deficit cutting legislation is passed the President could again borrow more money. Importantly Congress cannot amend or filibuster any plan; it can only approve or reject it. The committee has met and considered the options. Unfortunately for the nation the members are evenly split on their proposals and thus no plan has been sent to Congress. This impasse and the impending cuts and caps have been termed the “fiscal cliff .”

It is fair to accuse both major political parties of playing politics when it comes to raising the debt limit. When Congress is in Republican hands they tend to pass legislation that raises America’s borrowing ceiling while the Democrats oppose it. When the Democrats control Congress they support legislation to raise the debt ceiling while the Republicans take a contrary position. The political debate surrounding the consideration of the Budget Act showed a shifting of political position of the parties, albeit some of their members had a clear understanding of the problem. Because the national debt is so large the interest payments are astronomical. The nation is continuing raising the debt ceiling to borrow more and more money to pay the interest due on the staggering debt. Some of the newer Republican members of the House of Representatives refused to follow the Party’s leadership and voted against the Budget Act. They did not believe that the debt ceiling should be raised without legislation that would greatly and permanently reduce